The recent film Saturday Night, directed by Jason Reitman, celebrates the origins of the iconic comedy show Saturday Night Live (SNL). However, the contrasting premiere of its 50th season reveals that SNL may be facing unprecedented challenges. While the show has cemented its status in American culture since its inception in 1975, it seems to be struggling to maintain its relevance in today’s rapidly changing media landscape.
Saturday Night serves as a fictional portrayal of the chaotic moments leading up to SNL’s first episode. It depicts the early struggles of SNL writer Rosie Shuster, played by Rachel Sennott, as she attempts to explain the innovative and unconventional nature of the show to an NBC executive. The film showcases the absurd humor that defined early sketches, like Andy Kaufman’s deadpan performance. While the film adds to the SNL mythology, it also highlights a disconnect between the past and the present.
SNL’s impact on television comedy is undeniable. It introduced memorable characters and catchphrases that have permeated popular culture, like Rachel Dratch’s Debbie Downer. The show has produced numerous comedic legends, from Bill Murray to Tina Fey, yet its once revolutionary edge seems to have dulled over time.
In an age dominated by social media, SNL appears to respond to cultural trends rather than set them. The recent season premiere featured a sketch that echoed online memes rather than showcasing original comedic brilliance. Although Maya Rudolph excelled in her portrayal of Kamala Harris, the overall humor felt stale and predictable, with moments that rarely matched the sharpness viewers have come to expect.
Despite the acknowledgment that SNL has always had its ups and downs, the current season’s premiere was particularly lackluster. Guest host Jean Smart, despite her acclaim for the HBO series Hacks, could not revive the show’s energy. The sketches, including a tired game show parody and a lackluster commercial, failed to impress critics.
SNL’s recent reliance on viral clips rather than cohesive episodes reflects a shift in how audiences consume comedy. The show garnered 3.1 billion views on social media last season, indicating that individual moments, rather than entire episodes, are driving viewership. This change raises questions about whether SNL can continue to thrive when it feels more iconic than relevant.
Additionally, SNL’s recent guest hosts have drawn criticism for their controversial choices, perceived as attempts to attract ratings rather than genuine comedy talent. High-profile figures like Donald Trump and Elon Musk have hosted, leading to backlash and protests, which undermines the show’s credibility as a satirical platform.
While Saturday Night attempts to pay homage to SNL’s history, it leaves viewers questioning its relevance today. The film’s portrayal of backstage chaos and the personalities behind the show lacks the urgency and humor that made SNL groundbreaking. Key moments, like Garrett Morris’s bold performance in the film, highlight the risks that SNL once took, contrasting sharply with its current, more cautious approach.
As SNL enters its 50th season, there is a growing concern about whether it can reclaim its status as a cultural touchstone. The show may need to rediscover its adventurous spirit, embracing fresh perspectives and innovative comedy. Ultimately, SNL stands at a crossroads, with the challenge of balancing its storied legacy with the need to remain pertinent in an ever-evolving media environment. More creativity and a return to its roots may be necessary for the show to reinvigorate itself and connect with audiences once more.
